A scoop of strawberry and a scoop of chocolate together… divine. It’s how I judge an ice cream shop lol. If they can’t do those flavors well there’s no hope.
Jeni's calls it green mint chip but the description below the name says peppermint. Some might say we're splitting hairs but peppermint has a stronger flavor to me. What do you think?
That's me with Praline Pecan and Rocky Road. I'd really like the pecan right now but I think I'd probably pick the Rocky Road most times, I don't think I could pick a flavor with no chocolate if ot really came down to it.
Butter pecan but only because the mint chocolate chip is green. White mint chocolate chip is far superior than green mint chocolate chip.
Oh and the butter ice cream base for the becan HAS to be butter flavored. Not butterscotch. Not caramel. Butter.
Cookie dough or cookies and cream. I’m a huge fan of a scoop of strawberry on top of either of those flavors lol but if I’m only getting one gotta go with the classics.
Geez... That's so hard. Um probably rocky road? I like the marshmallows in it. Though in Truth, my favorite is mixing broken up peanut butter cups, peanut butter frozen into little patties and hot fudge topping into vanilla ice cream. The peanut butter gives a slight nice boost of protein to help balance out the sugar. I dunno for me it helps with that sluggish feeling that normally comes after consumption of sweets.
Another question would be, "If you could only have onw for the rest of your life, which one?". I think I'm saying Vanilla, bc I do whatever with it. Even though I chose Pralines and Cream here.
The history of Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Butter pecan ice cream was invented because black people were denied vanilla ice cream (except with a special coupon only to be used on July 4th) because it was seen as “pure” and for white people only, during slavery and after through the Jim Crow segregation era.
They were limited to only be able to purchase and eat chocolate ice cream throughout the year. Mind you, it was a young black enslaved man by the name of Edmund Albius who revolutionized the cultivation of vanilla to be used in the ice cream in the first place. 😏 So what did black people do? They added, pecans, and butter to the vanilla ice cream so they would have variety and it was no longer “pure white”. We are certainly an innovative people. Thus the love affair of black people and butter pecan ice cream.
Totally depends on the brand!
Private selection brand from Kroger: definitely chocolate. Their chocolate ganache flavor is so good.
Tillamook: mint chocolate chip or cookies and cream depending on my mood
Just leave out the bottom row and I'm good. Hell I would be ok with just omitting Rocky Road. Frozen, rock hard peanuts in ice cream? Get the fuck out.
I just happened to have this conversation with my husband last night. I’d choose chocolate, strawberry and cookies & cream. His were vanilla, mint chip and strawberry.
Neapolitan cus then I can just add my own toppings to make any of these😝 but for real…. I chooooose the last row😂😂🤦🏼♀️ … the real answer is .. if u love me why would u make me choose just give me all the flavors for all my moods that need ice cream to make that moment special 😝😅🤦🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️❤️🙌🏼we all win
I think I gotta say cookie dough
It is the best.
It's midnight, I can't possibly make this kind of decision right now
It's your hypothetical world, just eat them all!!!
Cookies and cream
Absolutely!!
Without a doubt
This is the way.
With gummy bears or worms 😋
This is the only answer. Timeless classic.
Pistacchio?
Spumoni is so boss.
OMFG spumoni is top tier!
Ah a fellow pistachio ice cream connoisseur. I was hoping someone would give it an honorable mention
I'm the weird one! I love strawberry 😌 i barley like sweets but there is something about strawberries and cream I just love it..
Throughout heaven and earth, strawberry alone is the honored one.
A scoop of strawberry and a scoop of chocolate together… divine. It’s how I judge an ice cream shop lol. If they can’t do those flavors well there’s no hope.
Right there with ya, friend.
Mint chocolate chip always has a special place in my heart ❤️
Chance the rapper has a Ben and Jerries mint chocolate that's fucking incredible
Butter pecan!
Vanilla!
the best !!
It really is! You can basically add anything to it (love butterscotch topping)
Nothing better than a quality vanilla
I love a strong vanilla taste
Pralines and cream
Going with you on this one, but only because the best ever choice, Chocolate Peanut Butter, is not an option.
Ooh - get this. Pralines n cream and PB & chocolate together are amazing - especially Baskin-Robbins…
Absolutely true. I have actually done that double scoop combo at B-R. It’s fantastic.
Haagen-Dazs' peanut butter and chocolate is also very good.
Mint chocolate chip
Man of culture
I'm stuck on Baskin Robbins mint chocolate chip. Which one is your favorite?
If you like the Baskin Robbins one, try the Talenti or Jenis ones 🔥
Jeni's calls it green mint chip but the description below the name says peppermint. Some might say we're splitting hairs but peppermint has a stronger flavor to me. What do you think?
Not OP but I like turkey hill and Tillamook
Strawberry
But only if it's Häagen-Dazs
If those are my only options it's chocolate. But where's my coffee?
My heart is right now saying butter pecan, but I have to go with cookie dough! I can’t let my current feelings influence my track record of loyalty.
That's me with Praline Pecan and Rocky Road. I'd really like the pecan right now but I think I'd probably pick the Rocky Road most times, I don't think I could pick a flavor with no chocolate if ot really came down to it.
Butter pecan
I don't see any chocolate peanut butter in here
cookie dough
I can’t choose! Strawberry, mint chocolate chip & chocolate. Neapolitan ice cream is a solid go-to for me.
Strawberry
Strawberry
Butter pecan but only because the mint chocolate chip is green. White mint chocolate chip is far superior than green mint chocolate chip. Oh and the butter ice cream base for the becan HAS to be butter flavored. Not butterscotch. Not caramel. Butter.
Chocolate, i can dress it up or just enjoy it!
Chocolate
Butter pecan
FUCK. it's such a hard toss between strawberry and cookies and cream... bc I LOVE mixing strawberry & cookies and cream ice cream together 🥺
Cookie dough😩😩😩
Impossible
Pralines and cream.
The correct answer is always chocolate. 🍫😍
Butter pecan
Mint chocolate chip
Pralines and cream!!@
Pralines and cream.
pralines n cream
Pralines and cream. Though if I picked vanilla, I could add syrups and nuts to make it other flavors, too.
Pralines and Cream
double chocolate cookie dough
Rocky Road.
Pralines and cream all day!
Neapolitan
Cookie dough
I’ll have that whole middle row
Classic cookie dough will always be a favorite of mine!
Cookie dough for me
Mint chocolate chip has been my favorite since I was a kid (but recently I’ve been on the Cookie Dough Express)
Rocky Road
Rocky road.
Rocky Road Mint Chocolate Chip Chocolate
Cookies and cream
Butter Pecan with fresh ground sea salt on top…🤩
Cookie dough
Butter Pecan
Peanut butter and chocolate but I don’t see that option on here 😭
Cookie dough
Cookie dough or cookies and cream. I’m a huge fan of a scoop of strawberry on top of either of those flavors lol but if I’m only getting one gotta go with the classics.
Cookie dough
Cookie dough without hesitation
Cookie Dough
Cookie dough 🍪
I’m a cookie dough girl til the day I die
Cookie dough
Cookie dough
Cookie dough
Cookie dough
Cookie dough forever
Cookie dough!!!!
Cookie dough 🤭
Safe pick: vanilla.
Blasphemy. There’s always room for another scoop.
I’m torn between vanilla and cookies + cream 🤦🏽♂️
Cookies and cream
Vanilla.
Do many people still like the bottom 3 as favorite? Feels kinda 1980's.
Cookies & Cream
Easily mint chocolate chip
Cookies and cream.
Cookies and Cream if I had to pick. Vanilla and chocolate take second and third, respectively.
Geez... That's so hard. Um probably rocky road? I like the marshmallows in it. Though in Truth, my favorite is mixing broken up peanut butter cups, peanut butter frozen into little patties and hot fudge topping into vanilla ice cream. The peanut butter gives a slight nice boost of protein to help balance out the sugar. I dunno for me it helps with that sluggish feeling that normally comes after consumption of sweets.
Mint chocolate chip is awesome!
C & C 👊
Cookies & Cream
Vanilla baby LFG
Out of these it’d have to be strawberry
Another question would be, "If you could only have onw for the rest of your life, which one?". I think I'm saying Vanilla, bc I do whatever with it. Even though I chose Pralines and Cream here.
Strawberry
Cookies and cream 🍦🍦🍦
Vanilla... because you can turn it into all these flavors and more!
I'm really stuck between chocolate and cookie dough. Chocolate.
Out of these, chocolate but out of all flavors, peanut butter
MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP. I want some now. Runner up Dutch chocolate almond. I miss Lics.
Butter Pecan! THAT is the one real answer!
Out of all these… mint Then the cookie ones
Vanilla. I love it.
There can be only one!! And that one is Strawberry.
Cookies and cream
Mint chocolate chip!!
Real easy rocky road, it has to be Häagen-Dazs pint. That marshmallow glob is like c****
Cookies and cream
Where is Vanilla Chocolate Chip. I die on that hill
cookies and cream all the way
Strawberry. Full on. I can put down a tub of Edy’s in a day, no problem. Edy’s. 😅
Cookies and cream, ALWAYS.
Im a simple girl. Vanilla. But that is no reason to think the bedroom is 😂
vanilla i can't stand chocolate ice cream (unsure why) but i love vanilla
Strawberry
Butter pecan alllll day
From those choices, mint chocolate chip, but my ultimate favorite is peppermint stick.
Chocolate
The history of Butter Pecan Ice Cream Butter pecan ice cream was invented because black people were denied vanilla ice cream (except with a special coupon only to be used on July 4th) because it was seen as “pure” and for white people only, during slavery and after through the Jim Crow segregation era. They were limited to only be able to purchase and eat chocolate ice cream throughout the year. Mind you, it was a young black enslaved man by the name of Edmund Albius who revolutionized the cultivation of vanilla to be used in the ice cream in the first place. 😏 So what did black people do? They added, pecans, and butter to the vanilla ice cream so they would have variety and it was no longer “pure white”. We are certainly an innovative people. Thus the love affair of black people and butter pecan ice cream.
Typically pralines and cream are not grouped in with “pick your favorite “ so there is only one option for me. I’ll take both.
Chocolate is the way to go
Totally depends on the brand! Private selection brand from Kroger: definitely chocolate. Their chocolate ganache flavor is so good. Tillamook: mint chocolate chip or cookies and cream depending on my mood
Cookies and cream
cookies & cream, always and forever
Strawberry
MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP💚
It’s gonna have to be cookies and cream… but there needs to be tons of cookie!
Mint chocolate chip!
Is butter pecan and pralines and cream the same ice cream?
Mint chocolate chip
IMPORTANT QUESTION. re: vanilla. is it plain vanilla? or can it be french vanilla or vanilla bean???
Where is the chocolate chip?
It’s between mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream
Man this is hard. I think rocky road though 🤔
Butter pecan
ROCKY ROAD! ROCKY ROAD! ROCKY ROAD!
Rocky road
Butter pecan
Why mint chocolate chip of course
Rocky Road every time
I think I’ll have to go with butter pecan or pralines and cream!
Yes
Mint chocolate chip
mint chocolate chip. anyone who says its tastes like toothpaste has a dirty mouth
Mint chocolate chip duh
Of these it'd be mint chip.
Mint chocolate chip for sure
Cookies and cream
OG cookies and cream
Estroberry
Butter Pecan
Strawberry
*Butter Pecan*
Cookies and cream
Vanilla and toppings just hits different
Just leave out the bottom row and I'm good. Hell I would be ok with just omitting Rocky Road. Frozen, rock hard peanuts in ice cream? Get the fuck out.
I just happened to have this conversation with my husband last night. I’d choose chocolate, strawberry and cookies & cream. His were vanilla, mint chip and strawberry.
Cookie Dough
Mint chocolate chip I’m feeling frisky
Neapolitan cus then I can just add my own toppings to make any of these😝 but for real…. I chooooose the last row😂😂🤦🏼♀️ … the real answer is .. if u love me why would u make me choose just give me all the flavors for all my moods that need ice cream to make that moment special 😝😅🤦🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️❤️🙌🏼we all win
STRAWBERRY
The lack of coffee, mocha, or pistachio here is unreal.
Mint chocolate chip FTW
Tie between strawberry and chocolate
Pralines & Cream
BUTTER PECAN
Vanilla- most versatile
Cookies n cream
Cookie dough!!!
Pralines and cream for sure. Mayfield is the only one I’ve ever found.
Mint chocolate chip
Cookie dough or Rocky road
Heavenly Hash
It's coffee. Which isn't even here.
Mint forever ♥️
Mint chocolate chip. Bite me
Whatever one strikes your fancy right now. Mine: Rocky road.
Donde esta peanut butter and chocolate